Understanding home inspection report ratings

Last updated

How Texas checkboxes, ASHI and Florida report language, and InterNACHI material defects differ, and what a rating does not require anyone to fix.

Nothing in federal law assigns home defects a universal color, number, or letter grade. What matters is the legend printed on the report you received. A red row in one software product, a “marginal” tag in another, and a checked box on a state form can describe very different judgments. Read the definition on that report, then read the comment under the item. The comment is where the inspector has to say what was seen.

Three published systems show how far apart those definitions can be: Texas’s mandatory form, the narrative categories in the ASHI standard and in Florida statute, and InterNACHI’s definition of a material defect.

Texas makes the inspector use four boxes

Licensed inspectors doing a real estate inspection in Texas use the Property Inspection Report form, REI 7-6. TREC’s instructions, citing 22 Texas Administrative Code § 535.223, say the inspector must check the appropriate box for every item to show whether it was Inspected (I), Not Inspected (NI), Not Present (NP), or Deficient (D). Checking the box is not enough. The inspector must also explain the findings in the matching section of the form. (trec.texas.gov)

The instructions spell out the boxes:

  • Inspected fits when any portion of that component or system is inspected.
  • Not Inspected fits when something is present but not inspected, when it should be present and is not and therefore could not be inspected, or when conditions keep the inspector from fully inspecting it.
  • Not Present fits when that component or system is not in the dwelling.
  • Deficient must be checked when, in the inspector’s reasonable judgment, a condition adversely and materially affects the performance of a system or component, or constitutes a hazard to life, limb, or property as the standards of practice specify.

More than one box can be checked. Both Inspected and Deficient apply when the item was inspected and a deficiency was found. Both Inspected and Not Inspected can apply when only part of a system was inspected, and the comments then have to say which part, and why the rest was skipped. If several boxes are checked, the inspector must explain why. (trec.texas.gov)

The form itself tells clients what a “D” does not do. Items marked Deficient do not obligate any party to make repairs or take other action. The decision to correct a hazard or any other reported deficiency is left to the parties to the sale contract. The form also says the inspector is not required to prioritize or emphasize one deficiency over another. A long run of D boxes is not a ranked punch list. Two items can carry the same letter and still be very different problems. The comments, not the letter, carry that difference. (trec.texas.gov)

The form is also explicit about older hazards. Conditions that did not violate the codes or common practice in effect when the home was built can still be marked Deficient if the inspector can reasonably determine they are present and the standards treat the injury or property-loss potential as serious enough to report. The form’s examples include missing or malfunctioning GFCI and AFCI protection, ordinary glass where current techniques call for safety glass, smoke alarms and other fire-safety features that are missing or not working, carbon monoxide alarms that malfunction, excessive spacing between stair or porch balusters, improperly installed appliances, defective safety devices, missing electrical bonding and grounding, and missing bonding on gas piping, including CSST. Reporting those items does not, by itself, mean a city will require them to be brought up to a newer code. The form says older conditions may not have to be updated. It still wants them marked D when the standards say they are hazardous. (trec.texas.gov)

A few other sentences on the same form keep the rating from being misread as a guarantee. The inspection is a visual survey and a basic performance evaluation of conditions that are present, visible, and accessible that day. It is not a technically exhaustive inspection, not a check of building-code compliance, and not a check of the manufacturer’s installation instructions. It does not imply that the structure or its components are insurable or warrantable. If a comment says further evaluation is needed, the form places that follow-up on the client, and it recommends getting evaluations and cost estimates before contractual time limits, such as an option period, run out. Repairs done after the inspection date can make the report’s information obsolete. (trec.texas.gov)

Association language and Florida’s statute use sentences, not four letters

ASHI’s Standard of Practice tells subscribing inspectors to give the client a written report identifying inspected systems and components that, in the inspector’s professional judgment, are not functioning properly, are significantly deficient, are unsafe, or are near the end of their service lives. The report should recommend correction, monitoring, or further evaluation. It should explain the nature of those deficiencies when the reason is not self-evident. It should also name systems and components that were present but not inspected, and say why. ASHI says the inspector is not required to determine methods, materials, or costs of corrections. There is no required red-yellow-green scale in that standard. (homeinspector.org)

Florida’s report statute is narrower than ASHI’s list and still does not create a numbered grade. After a paid home inspection, Florida Statutes § 468.8323 requires a written report for the client. The inspector must report on inspected systems and components that, in the inspector’s professional opinion, are significantly deficient or near the end of their service lives. If the reason is not self-evident, the report must give a reason. The report must also list systems and components that were present but not inspected, with a reason. The statute says a home inspector is not required to provide repair-cost estimates. It does not define “significantly deficient” with a point scale. The professional opinion, and the sentences under it, are the rating. (flsenate.gov)

InterNACHI’s standard, last revised October 2022 on the association’s site, uses a different trigger. A home inspection report shall identify, in writing, defects within the systems the standards name that the inspector both observed and deemed material. A material defect is a specific issue that may have a significant, adverse impact on the value of the property, or that poses an unreasonable risk to people. The same definition says the fact that a system or component is near, at, or beyond the end of its normal useful life is not, in itself, a material defect. (nachi.org)

That last sentence is the comparison that saves people from arguing past each other. An aging water heater that still operates might be described as near the end of its service life in an ASHI-style report or in a Florida report. Under InterNACHI’s definition, age alone is not a material defect. Neither wording is a secret code for “walk away” or “ignore it.” Ask which standard the report claims to follow before you treat one company’s “monitor” and another company’s “material defect” as the same judgment. The standards of practice guide goes further into what those documents include and leave out.

An illustration, not a real house

Picture two comments that both sit under a Deficient box on a Texas-style form. One says a toilet in a hall bath is loose at the floor. The other says there are active stains and daylight at a roof penetration over the living room. The letter on both rows can be D. TREC does not require the inspector to rank them. The comments are the part a buyer, a seller, and a contractor would actually talk through. This pairing is an illustration of how the form works. It does not come from any specific address, and it does not try to predict a repair cost.

The same caution applies to color dots printed by private software. Unless the report defines the color, the color is the company’s house style. Ask for that definition. If the software says “safety” and the comment describes a missing GFCI, you can compare that comment with the Texas form’s hazard examples when the house is in Texas. If the house is somewhere else, compare the comment with the standard named in the agreement, not with a legend from a different state.

What these ratings refuse to decide

InterNACHI’s limitations say an inspection does not determine market value, marketability, insurability, or whether buying the property is advisable. It will not identify concealed or latent defects, and it is not technically exhaustive. Cosmetic items and matters of taste are outside that standard. A rating, even a severe-sounding one, is not an appraisal and not a lender’s underwriting decision. (nachi.org)

The CFPB draws the same line from the buyer’s side. The inspection and the appraisal are different, and you generally need both when you are borrowing. If the inspection report leads you to want repairs, a credit, or a cancellation, that result depends on your purchase contract and on whether the seller agrees. The bureau says a contract contingent on a satisfactory inspection can allow cancellation without penalty when you are not satisfied. It does not say a particular rating forces the seller to pay. (consumerfinance.gov)

How to move from the legend to a decision

Start with three documents on the table: the report, the legend or standard it cites, and the purchase contract’s inspection clause. Sort comments into items you understand, items that need a specialist, and items that were present but not inspected. Texas clients are told to obtain further evaluations from qualified service professionals on deficient items, ideally before the contractual clock expires. Other states do not use this form, so confirm the deadline in your own contract with your agent or a lawyer. (trec.texas.gov)

If a comment points past a visual inspection, toward a sewer camera, a radon test, a mold evaluation, or an engineer, that next visit is a different scope. Home inspector vs specialist inspections separates those jobs. If you later believe something visible was missed, Your home inspector missed something is the place to start, with the report and the agreement still in hand.

A rating is a label tied to a definition. It does not, by itself, order a repair, set a price, or tell you the house is safe in every hidden place. If a sentence in the report is unclear, ask the inspector to explain that sentence in writing while you still have time to use the answer.

Sources

  1. Property Inspection Report Form (REI 7-6) | TREC
  2. Property Inspection Report Form instructions | TREC
  3. ASHI Standard of Practice
  4. Florida Statutes § 468.8323, Home inspection report
  5. InterNACHI Home Inspection Standards of Practice
  6. Schedule a home inspection | Consumer Financial Protection Bureau